Wednesday, December 13, 2017

Another perspective on the passthroughs

Mark the Knife posted a comment on a prior blog post of mine in this series. As I found it perceptive, I hope he doesn't mind my pasting it in here:

The push for a passthrough tax seemed based on some sort of odd understanding by members of Congress regarding "fairness" between passthrough businesses and C corps. I think there's a sense that corporate E&P is (ignoring the fact it isn't really "income") capital income par excellence, and income from passthroughs which is like E&P should receive the special rate.

So if I were to say what the theory behind the guardrails is intended to be, it's: If this passthrough were a business operating as a C corporation, would a particular allocation of income be retained (or allowed to be retained) in earnings and profits? If so, it deserves the special rate. Else, it should get the regular rate.

You can then see the two bills as focusing on a different problem--the House hates that labor income could be disguised as "E&P-like" income, and the Senate is aimed at attacking passthroughs that are the equivalent of corporate pocketbooks (a sort of personal holding company rule, but one that determines classification by looking to employment by a holding company instead of its income).

I don't think this is a terrific theory by any means, and certainly each bill deviates in some way from this theory, but it's my best shot at a cohesive theory thus far.

(Back to me): This strikes me as a very plausible account of how some of the thinking might have developed. Unfortunately, as grounds for policy it's incoherent nonsense (as I suspect Mark the Knife would agree).

A C corporation's E&P is kind of, very roughly, its "capital income" if not swelled by underpayment of salary to owner-employees. In a pure public company where only deductible compensation is paid to employees who lack significant owner interests, it's kind of a match for capital income, defined as the residue after paying labor costs, only it may include rents that a consumption tax would reach, not just normal returns that it would exempt. If you're using expensing to exempt the normal return, why exactly do you need to also have a low tax rate here? This was one of the points about the DBCFT - in principal the rate could be high without driving out capital a la an origin-based corporate income tax.

Now we go to the passthrough setting, and supposedly equity as between different types of entities - a nonsensical concept since (a) only people matter and (b) passthrough owners can incorporate - dictates also giving a low rate to the passthrough income that's left after paying out salary. Only, here we are very far from the setting of a publicly owned company in which owner-employees may only own a smallish piece. In the classic passthrough, a small group of owners has the whole thing, and has little need to pay themselves salary as that's just moving money between pockets of the same suit. So they all underpay themselves labor income, at least once the new law is in place, and they want a lower rate because - well, just because.

Mark the Knife's final nice point goes to the House versus the Senate having different aims. Apparently Ryan et al hate lawyers and such more, while in the Senate maybe they hate ?? more? (Not quite sure who they're after or why.)

I guess we'll see what comes out in conference, but we can be sure that it will still have no coherent rationale.

10 comments:

Anonymous said...

Life indeed is GRACE, I'am Daan Sophia currently in California USA. I would like to share my experience with you guys on how I got a loan of $185,000.00 USD to clear my bank draft and start up a new business. It all started when i lost my home and belongings due to the bank draft I took to offset some bills and some personal needs. I became so desperate and began to seek for funds at all means. Luckily for me I heard a colleague of mine talking about this company, I got interested although i was scared of being scammed, I was compelled by my situation and had no choice than to seek advise from my friend regarding this very company and was given their contact number, getting intouch with them really made me skeptical due to my past experience with online lenders, little did i know this very Company "PROGRESSIVE LOAN INC. was a godsent to me and my family and the entire Internet World, this company has been of great help to me and some of my colleague and today am a proud owner of well organized business and responsibilities are well handled all thanks to Josef Lewis of (progresiveloan@yahoo.com).. So if really you are genuinely in need of a loan either to expand or start up your own business or in any form of financial difficulty, i advise you give Mr Josef Lewis of Progressive loan the opportunity of financial upliftment in your life Email: progresiveloan@yahoo.com OR Call/Text +1(603) 786-7565 and not fall victim of online scam in the name of getting a loan. thanks

Dr Purva Pius said...

I’m Charles David by name, i want to use this medium to alert all loan seekers to be very careful because there are scam everywhere, Few months ago I was financially strained, and due to my desperation I was scammed by several online lenders. I had almost lost hope until a friend of mine referred me to a very reliable lender called Dr Purva Pius ( A God fearing man) who lend me a loan of $237,000 under 72 working hours without any stress. I explain to the company by mail and all they told me was to cry no more because i will get my loan from this company and also i have made the right choice of contacting them i filled the loan application form and proceeded with all that was requested of me and to my shock I was given the loan, If you are in need of any kind of loan just contact him now via: {urgentloan22@gmail.com}

I‘m using this medium to alert all loan seekers because of the hell I passed through in the hands of those fraudulent lenders.

Thanks you Dr Purva Pius Loan service for your help.

Mrs Sharon Sim said...

Hello Everybody,
My name is Mrs Sharon Sim. I live in Singapore and i am a happy woman today? and i told my self that any lender that rescue my family from our poor situation, i will refer any person that is looking for loan to him, he gave me happiness to me and my family, i was in need of a loan of S$250,000.00 to start my life all over as i am a single mother with 3 kids I met this honest and GOD fearing man loan lender that help me with a loan of S$250,000.00 SG. Dollar, he is a GOD fearing man, if you are in need of loan and you will pay back the loan please contact him tell him that is Mrs Sharon, that refer you to him. contact Dr Purva Pius,via email:(urgentloan22@gmail.com) Thank you.

mabel said...

INSTEAD OF GETTING A LOAN,, I GOT SOMETHING NEW
Get $5,500 USD for six months!
See how it works
Do you know you can hack into any ATM machine with a hacked Atm card??
Make up you mind before applying, straight deal...
Order for a blank Atm card now and get millions within a week!: contact us
via email address: securehackers01@gmail.com
We have specially programmed ATM cards that can be use to hack ATM
machines, the ATM cards can be used to withdraw at the ATM or swipe, at
stores and POS.
you order via [securehackers01@gmail.com]
Here is our price list for ATM cards:
BALANCE PRICE
$5,000----------------$300
$10,000 ------------- $650
$20,000 ------------- $1,200
$35,000 --------------$1,900
$50,000 ------------- $2,700
$100,000------------- $5,200
make up your mind before applying, straight deal!!!
The price include delivery fees and charges, order now: contact us via
email address: securehackers01@gmail.com

Unknown said...

ALL THANKS TO UPSTART LOAN AM NOW FINANCIALLY STABLE . upstartloan@yahoo.com
I am Michelle Huxford from Casper, Wyoming. I was in a very chronic financial issue and terminal health situation some few weeks back. After all my search for assistance from friends and neighbors proved abortive, I feel there was no one who truly cares. I became so emaciated due to lack of good food and my 2 kids age 5 and 8 were not also good looking due to lack of proper care as a result of finance. One faithful morning I saw an old time friend of my late husband and I told him all I have been going through and he said the only way he could help was to direct me to a good loan agency that also helped him, He explained to me on how he was financially down and how he got boosted by this loan agency UPSTART LOAN INC ( upstartloan@yahoo.com ) who grant him 245,000 USD loan at an affordable rate. He further assured me that they were the only legit loan firm he found in the quest of seeking for loan after been scammed by various fake loan lenders online. He gave me their email: upstartloan@yahoo.com or text/call (574) 301-1639, That was how i applied and was also granted a loan and my life changed for the good. CONTACT THE ONLY GENUINE LENDERS( UPSTART LOAN INC) VIA email: upstartloan@yahoo.com or call +1 (574) 301-1639 to resolve your financial mess.

Unknown said...

Good day Loan Seekers Solution for your financial problems......
We are a fully registered and certified loan firm, that offers secured and unsecured loans to individuals and companies at a very low interest rate of 2%. We offer long and short term loans.Our company has recorded a lot of breakthroughs in the provision of first class financial services to our clients, especially in the area of Loan syndication and capital provision for individuals and companies. We have brought ailing industries back to life and we back good business ideas by providing funds for their up start. We have a network of Investors that are willing to provide funds of whatever amount to individuals and organizations to start business and operations.We are a group of energetic and experienced loan professionals with thorough knowledge of financial markets.In general we offer mortgages, home loans business loans and bad credit loans commercial loans, start-up- working capital loans construction loans car loans, hotel loans Xmas loans Our interest rate is 2% per annual repaid, our loan takes a maximum of 3 working days to get to all approved customers across the globe.You can contact us clintonnancy43@gmail.com

Unknown said...

i am Alex i was in need of a loan to pay my debt and i was seeking for a legit loan company that could help me with a loan of $ 750 thousand dollars but i was decline of getting the amount i needed and along the line i was introduced to a private loan lender Mrs julie jones which i tried my best to give a try and i was asked to come and pay a fee which i refused because i was scared to be scammed for the second time because of my bad experience i have by trying to get this very important loan to pay my debt but Mrs julie jones gave me her word of advice and told me i am in the right place of getting a loan and i was lucky for the loan i applied for. contact via yahoo mail (juliejonesloancompany@yahoo.com)

janaz said...

How I Got My Blank ATM Card And Became Weathy...

I'am Janaz Russ, my husband and i are here to testify about how we use williams ATM blank card to make money and also have our own business today. Go get your blank ATM card today and be among the lucky ones. This PROGRAMMED blank ATM card is capable of hacking into any ATM machine, anywhere in the world. It has really changed our life for good and now we can say we are rich and we can never be poor again. You can withdraw the maximum of $ 10,000 daily We can proudly say our business is doing fine and we have up to 20,000 000 (20 millions dollars in our account) Is not illegal, there is no risk of being caught because it has been programmed in such a way that it is not traceable, it also has a technique that makes it impossible for the CCTV to detect you.. For details and cost on how to get yours today, email the hackers on: (nashwilliams4@gmail.com)....

johnny said...

Are you interested in the service of a hacker to get into a phone, facebook account, snapchat, Instagram, yahoo, Whatsapp, get verified on any social network account, increase your followers by any amount, bank wire and bank transfer. Contact him on= ETHICALHACKERS009@GMAIL.COM

OR WHATSAPP +1 213 295 1376

Catherine said...

Salutations à vous. Nous proposons des prêts garantis et non garantis à des taux d'intérêt très bas de 2% Nous proposons des prêts personnels, des prêts de consolidation de dettes, du capital-risque, des prêts commerciaux, des prêts d'études, des prêts immobiliers ou des prêts de toute façon ! Contactez-nous par mail: catherinebourgeat.fr@gmail.com ! Cordialement