Friday, July 01, 2005

Bad, but not self-contradictory

Although I consider Social Security a key part of my beat here, I initially didn't comment on the DeMint proposal to revive Bush's private accounts by funding the accounts with the annual Social Security cash flow surplus for as long as it lasts, for two reasons. The first was that it seemed too silly to be worth much attention. The second went to comparative advantage as a commentator. While I think I have a good conceptual feel for how to analyze Social Security policy at a broad normative level, I certainly don't have the institutional knowledge about different reform plans that economists who have gotten into the issue possess. This analysis by Jason Furman and Robert Greenstein seemed to me to pretty much do the job that needed to be done in evaluating the DeMint proposal.

But I enter the fray now for two reasons. The first is that I gather this highly dubious plan is actually going somewhere. I simply raised my eyebrows initially when, for example, Wall Street Journal editorials trumpeted the claim that the proposal had fundamentally transformed the public debate about Social Security reform. (I'm not sure what polls they were reading, or what they were smoking.) But recent reports suggest that the House Republican leadership is considering trying to pass it, even though it presumably it has no chance in the Senate. My second reason for weighing in here is that I now feel I have something to say about it, pertaining to the sorts of fiscal language issues that I am writing about these days.

Critics of the DeMint plan who were less well versed in it than Furman and Greenstein have argued that it shows Republican hypocrisy in the following sense. First the Republicans said the Trust Fund is meaningless, as in Bush's photo op in front of the file cabinets, but now they say it is meaningful and they want to use it.

For what it's worth, I think the Republican stance on this actually is internally intellectually consistent. First they say the Trust Fund is meaningless, because it's spent as it comes in, leaving behind nothing but IOUs. Then they say, let's prevent this from happening by actually spending it as it comes in to help Social Security beneficiaries.

Unfortunately, being internally intellectual consistent, while a virtue of a sort, is not enough. A key fallacy on which the DeMint plan rests (or alternatively, that it tries to exploit) is that Social Security participants are helped by spending these particular dollars on them. Problem # 1, money is fungible. Problem # 2, when you're on an unsustainable path, promising new benefits without any new net financing (other than possibly future cutbacks in traditional Social Security benefits) doesn't help. Problem # 3, making the government's fiscal picture worse via new unfunded benefits (see Furman and Greenstein for the point that there is no reason to expect this plan to increase the prudence of other Congressional decisions) is not especially helpful to the people whose future benefits are made even more unaffordable. Problem # 4 (applying to the extent that ## 2 and 3 don't), presumably the people who get the new accounts would be forced to pay something for them via traditional benefit cutbacks, just as under the Bush plan. So this is really just the Bush plan all over again on a smaller scale that has no coherent rationale and that, in some ways, as Furman and Greenstein show (e.g., administrative costs relative to the $$ per account) actually makes it worse.

The political appeal of the DeMint plan (if any) rests on its exploiting the fallacy that, by doing it this way instead of the Bush way, we actually aren't taking money from Social Security because it's just the surplus that would otherwise have been diverted. But if there is a diversion under one, then there is a diversion under both. Or, viewed more accurately, promising new benefits makes no sense, and avoiding net cost by trading fixed for risky benefits makes no sense in the Social Security context, since the idea is to assure people who may be imprudent some minimum level of retirement resources, and since people with other net saving can invest as riskily as they like anyway.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Are you finally ready to get out of all the fast-money games? Are you finally ready to create a future with a affiliate internet marketing program with real products so far ahead of it's time that nothing else even comes close?!?

Anonymous said...

Are You an Advanced Marketer? Click here to learn how to broadcast thousands of messages directly to people's desktops with just a click from your mouse, Spam Free. Learn more about it here: low cost multi-level marketing site. It pretty much covers low cost multi-level marketing related stuff and it is FREE to join.

Anonymous said...

Like your site about cash america pawn.
I've got a new site about cash america pawn.
Please come check it out.

Anonymous said...

Saw your blog about account bank business free - as it is along the same lines I thought I would share this link with you. We were paying far too much for family things like clothes for us and the kids, games consoles inc the new Wii and soon to be PS3, car insurance/home insurance/pet insurance, broadband, mobile phones, landline calls, home and garden items, camping equipment and utilities/loans etc - you name it, we were spending too much on it.

Then a friend of mine recommended a site called www.bargainplace.co.uk. We were able to get cheaper electricity, gas, mobile phone, broadband and loan deals at bargainplace. Thanks to my friend (and the site) I am saving something like £100 a month and can afford an extra holiday abroard each year. Booked of course on www.bargainplace.co.uk. Thanks bargainplace ;-) !!

Anonymous said...

Great blog on honest extra income at home. I've stumbled on a superb money making website. Linkreferral is free to join and drives traffic to your website in an inivitive way (the more sites you visit, the more links you get back to your website.)

I've only been a member of Linkreferral for aproximately 2 weeks but I have already seen the volume of people coming to my site double - if not treble.

Linkreferral is not only driving visitors to my website but as a result my affiliate sales income has doubled also.

I really cannot push this website enough. It is free and it is fantastic!! www.linkreferral.com is a must for money making opportunities online.

Anonymous said...

.
.
.
.
.
.
Good blog - very interesting!! I liked it so much I'm going to share this hush hush advice with you. Ever wondered how your neighbours are driving around in their brand new BMW or Mercedes cars - with their kids dressed in all the latest named gear and foreign holidays aplenty?? Well they discovered the secret to the extra online income.

If you are looking for a free tool to attract loads of free links to your blog or website then congratulations I've got the solution for you - and it is FREE!!

My website specialises in ebay fee motor selling and to drive traffic to my website I was searching around the internet for absolutely ages looking for SEO tools and ffa submission sites to fire my site up the Google search engine - unfortunately these doing work and in fact had the opposite affect plunging my site down the rankings like it had a heavy weight attached!!, then I signed up for this free superb traffic generating tool - I now have loads of hits to my websites/blogs and my site is shooting back up the Google rankings quicker than ever before.

Consequently this saw my affiliate commissions shoot through the roof - meaning lots of extra money coming in for my family - I bought my first Mercedes car on the proceeds of my online campaign.
Sign up now - it's free.
. Sorry if this information is of no use to you but seeing as you have the anonymous feature enabled I thought I should share this free bit of essential promotional advice with you and would hope you would do the same for me and others who want to boost their online internet income.

I hope the tool will serve you equally as well as it has me - it's free!!

Best of luck, cheers for now, dave.
.
.
.
.
.
.

Anonymous said...

Good blog - very interesting!! Thought you might like some excellent advice on driving extra traffic to your website/blog - I'm into web hosting comparison and to drive traffic to my website I was searching around the internet for absolutely ages looking for SEO tools to fire my site up the Google search engine, then I signed up free for this superb traffic gereating tool - I now have loads of hits to my websites/blogs and my site is shooting up the Google rankings quicker than ever before.

Consequently this can see your affiliate commissions shoot through the roof - meaning lots of extra money coming in for you and your family. Sign up now - it's free.
. Sorry if this information is of no use to you but seeing as you have the anonymous feature enabled I thought I should share this free bit of essential promotional advice with you and would hope you would do the same for me.

I hope the tool will serve you equally as well as it has me!!

Best of luck, cheers for now, dave.