Monday, October 13, 2008

Paul Krugman wins the Nobel Economics Prize

Interesting to have this happen now; I have no idea whether the Nobel committee cares about Krugman's public intellectual role. He's obviously a meritorious pick in any event for his economics work, which reflected a trajectory from (a) challenging the conventional wisdom, such as about international trade, to show that things were a bit more complicated and ambiguous, to (b) defending the conventional wisdom against rejections of it that were ignorant and overstated.

A word on his life as a public intellectual, although it's unrelated to the Prize as such. While I have confidence in my own judgments and feel that they usually end up being vindicated, he certainly was right and I was wrong about Bush, say, in 2000 - he got there several years before I did, at a point when I thought that, despite the wacky tax and budget proposals, Bush would be reasonably safe and not that different from his dad. At the time I thought he was too selectively harsh against one side. This reflected that I didn't realize the full enormity of things, or how different it was from politics as usual, for several years after that. So unless it was just a lucky strike, Krugman truly deserves the Cassandra Prize as well (since Cassandra was disbelieved but right)

Some conservative economists I know will be gnashing their teeth. Not, however, Greg Mankiw, who offers a couple of links describing the economics work and criticizing (though reasonably and interestingly) the op-ed columns.

Friday, October 10, 2008

Budget deficit update

According to Martin Sullivan in the 10/6/08 Tax Notes, the budget deficit for 2009 could end up as high as $914 billion, or 6.2% of GDP, both of which would be all-time national records. This would reflect scoring the financial rescue plan on what seems the correct basis, if it can be done sufficiently accurately, which is to treat only the excess of outlays over the estimated present value of future receipts as a write-off.

Some time back I posted seemingly dire GAO estimates of rising budget deficits and public debt. Under those estimates, the deficit would not reach this level, relative to GDP, until the mid-2020s. So much for that.

True, this is a temporary phenomenon, reflecting both special outlays related to the financial meltdown and the counter-cyclical effects of a recession that, while it may be long-lasting, is merely part of the overall business cycle. In other words, it's reasonable to assume that annual deficits will decline again in a few years and only start rising again when baby boom retirement and the entitlements explosion really takes off.

Still, this is a huge hit on the amount of cushion that we have if we delay dealing with the long-term fiscal gap. Especially when one keeps in mind that there seem to be frequent adverse shocks. E.g., 9/11 followed by the Afghanistan and Iraq wars was one, and now this is another. While reasonable long-term forecasts won't treat a given adverse shock the same as a permanent change in tax and spending levels, they also shouldn't assume that there aren't going to be any more adverse shocks.

Yes, there are occasionally favorable shocks as well (e.g., the totally unanticipated revenue surge of the late 1990s, from some mix of real economic growth and the Internet, etc. bubble). But I'm putting my chips on a predominance of adverse shocks in the years ahead.

To put it all in perspective, if we manage to contain the current financial crisis it will be by virtue of using some of the fiscal cushion that we still have to buy ourselves out of trouble. But given everything else that is happening and not happening in Washington and the economy, this merely brings the fiscal crisis closer. That one, when and if it comes, will make the financial crisis look like a Sunday school picnic, and by definition we won't be able to buy our way out of it.

Thursday, October 09, 2008

Doug Holtz-Eakin, your thesis advisor is calling

His latest public statement was to the effect that Obama opposes the new McCain bailout plan because Obama just wants to help Wall Street, not Main Street.

Doug, did anyone tell you that the McCain plan is a direct pay to Wall Street, giving them face value rather than just market value for bad mortgages? Indeed, isn't it partly your plan? (I'd assume you helped draft it.)

Insert joke of choice here about Doug's earlier claim that McCain deserves credit for inventing the Blackberry.

This is a bit of a sensitive topic for me, because if McCain wins the election I will be praying that Doug gets to exert some influence on economic policy. After all, the alternatives in setting a McCain Administration's economic policy are presumably Steve Schmidt and Phil Gramm.

But O for the days when, say, Glenn Hubbard could represent an Administration with absymal budgetary policies and yet carefully avoid saying anything in public that was definitively false.

I recall, for example, Glenn's artistry (pointed out, almost but not quite with rueful admiration, in a blog entry by Brad DeLong many years back) when asked whether Bush's unending budget deficits would eventually raise interest rates. Option (a) would have been to admit that this was true. Glenn didn't want to do that. Option (b) would have been to lie and say it was false. Glenn didn't want to do that either. Option (c) was gracefully, almost imperceptibly (if you weren't watching carefully) to re-phrase the question as whether one or two years of budget deficits should be expected to raise interest rates. Then you could confidently and correctly say: No, as a matter of accepted economics that is incorrect. And that was what Glenn did.

I personally would not be comfortable spinning even to that degree, which is one reason why I do not thirst for public life, and thus would reject any offered post be it in a campaign or the government post-election. But if you do it that way you preserve a lot more of your academic reputation. Doug ought to take note, but I fear it's too late.

Staying calm in tough times

What do you tell yourself when, by market measures, your net worth declines by, say, a couple of hundred thousand dollars in the course of a week? (I haven't checked, but for someone my age with retirement saving it's a fair guess.)

I tell myself that all that's really changed is the median prediction for the future by a bunch of over-excitable folks who are playing Keynes' famous beauty contest game (trying to figure out who everyone else will think everyone else thinks is the winner).

In other words, though I accept the efficient capital markets hypothesis in the sense that I don't believe I can systematically make money by betting against market valuations, what's happened, I tell myself, is almost on a par with, say, the feeling a baseball fan should have if his team has a bad week in mid-August and the ESPN baseball analysts respond by downgrading the team by ten rungs or so in their weekly Power Rankings. There's arguably more heat than light to the change if you don't have to convert to cash any time soon.

Now, if only I could stay so serene about other things.

Monday, October 06, 2008

The time I met John McCain

Okay, I haven't told this story here yet. It was 1999. I had a book coming out soon on Social Security. Someone at NYU who handles press relations told me that Good Morning America was going to have John McCain stop by to discuss Social Security privatization (this being before that term was forbidden), and if I came I could ask him a question. For sure? I asked. Yes, she answered, the flacks at GMA assured me that you will get to ask a Social Security question on a widely watched national television show. OK, she knew the press angle better than I did.

For the record, while I considered Social Security privatization completely pointless, I wasn't by any means flat out hostile like most in my post-2001 political camp, and indeed had sketched out an idea that I called progressive privatization. What I liked about privatization, while recognizing that the stock market investment aspect was pointless and that it did nothing to ease the program's fiscal problems, was its being one way of clarifying the tax-benefit relationship for individual recipients that current Social Security assiduously obscures. You can read about it here or here.

Well, you know what Gore Vidal once said about being on television and one other thing - you can never have enough of either, he said - so, being next to unacquainted with the former, I headed up to midtown at some ungodly earthly hour, in order to get there by 6 am (or maybe it was even 5:30).

When I got there, I discovered that I had been totally scammed by the GMA flack, who had duped my NYU PR contact. They just wanted warm bodies to fill the room, most of them seemingly off a tourist bus. Everyone got to submit an index card and they would pick 3 to ask Senator McCain. Anything above the 6th grade level was definitely not wanted. (This had nothing to do with McCain but rather with the presumed TV audience for GMA.)

I should have just left, but like a cowed sheep in a herd of antelopes - I'm trying the Tom Friedman trick here of mixing and mangling the metaphors; it works (commercially) for him - I stayed around. Assiduous viewers (a couple of family members) got to see a couple of shots of me glowering from the back of the audience during McCain's gig, because I was so angry about having been conned to go there under false pretenses and way too early in the morning. The inconvenience, the disrespect, the lost sleep, the fact that I felt so used and foolish - but I digress.

At the end of the segment, they went to commercial and also were going to use a different part of the set for their next segment. So McCain, doing his duty as a politician, went through shaking hands with everyone in the crowd. No big thrill to me, though this was nothing particular against him; I simply don't have huge excitement about any of these guys, even though at the time I rated him much higher than I do now. But I didn't leave the set right away, because I wanted to find someone from the show to whom I could complain about having been lured there under false pretenses when all they wanted was a room full of warm bodies.

So I passed by McCain one more time. Thinking I wanted to shake his hand again, he snarled at me: "I already shook your hand!" (And "snarled" really is the right word here, though I don't mean to suggest he was out of control.)

This was a bit amusing given how little his or any other senator's hand means to me. Had I been a little quicker, I might have said something like "Relax, it's not like you're the Beatles or something."

I got two things out of it, a story to tell my Tax class later that morning (focused more on my mission of folly than McCain, but he supplied the capper), and a GMA long-sleeved T-shirt that I still wear in cold weather.

Friday, October 03, 2008

IRS Chief Counsel Donald Korb steps down

Courtesy of the Tax Prof blog, I gather that IRS Chief Counsel Don Korb has stepped down effective no later than next January 19, so that the next Administration can start right out with his successor.

This is not a surprise, since no one would be expected to want to stay in the Chief Counsel job forever. But I personally will be quite surprised if the new Chief Counsel is ready to be named by January 20. So I suspect that Korb will be asked, perhaps even implored, to stay on, although presumably from his announcement he does not wish to do so.

Suffice it to say that he is leaving large shoes to fill. Don Korb was amazingly energetic, entrepeneurial, and effective in filling the Chief Counsel post. He did a great deal to raise his office's profile and value, both to the government and to taxpayers. He innovated internally and externally, worked hard to strengthen his staff, and provided important outreach and guidance that was good for everyone. The next Administration will be very lucky to find anyone who can match his job performance.

Thursday, October 02, 2008

VP debate - not the comment readers might expect

I really can't watch these things straight through - too tedious and stupid an experience for me.

But I would give a lot of money to put an end to the faux populism that resonates everywhere in American politics. All these durn "regular folks" who want your vote while pretending they have no money and aren't famous & powerful. Not just the supposed hockey mom - it's a phony and annoying tic that apparently is obligatory for everyone. And it's a strange tic to have in a country that is so much less committed to equality than nearly every western European country.

This is not a rant but an observation - there is a trade-off between efficiency and redistribution, which one can reasonably resolve at various points along the continuum, certainly including the American one. But it truly is odd for a country that's so much less egalitarian than the norm to be so rabidly committed to fake gestures of anti-elitism, invariably orchestrated by leaders of elites.

Wednesday, October 01, 2008

A nice heap of sugar

The Senate passed the bailout bill tonight after sweetening it with $150 billion ($110 billion net of offsets) in new tax breaks, including "extenders" that no doubt will soon be extended again. The bill, originally just 3 pages (although that gave the Treasury excessive authority without oversight), now apparently exceeds 450 pages. Good work, guys.

In a country with a massive and growing fiscal gap, the potential $700 billion cost already was a huge problem. Yes, I know in theory the Treasury might even end up turning a profit on this, but the incentive issues and institutional skill set make me skeptical. Other countries have apparently flipped assets for a profit in this setting, but these days, no matter what the task, ours always seems to be the government that can't.

We are converting the financial crisis into a worsening of the fiscal crisis, and while this particular drop in the bucket may be small, it demonstrates once again the fecklessness that really is worse than anything about the current fiscal projections.

Diane Rogers is right: "a teaspoon of sugar helps the medicine go down." But it's also true that sugar all the time eventually wrecks the teeth, the taste buds, and the digestive system.

Thursday, September 25, 2008

2009 NYU Tax Policy Colloquium

It's never too soon. In that spirit, here is the schedule for the 2009 NYU Tax Policy Colloquium, which I will be co-teaching with Alan Auerbach:

SCHEDULE FOR 2009 NYU TAX POLICY COLLOQUIUM
(All sessions meet on Thursdays from 4-6 pm in Furman 120, NYU Law School)

1. January 15 – Daniel Shaviro, NYU Law School. The Long-Term Fiscal Gap: Is the Main Problem Generational Equity?
2. January 22 – Alan Auerbach, Berkeley Economics Department and NYU Law School.
3. January 29 – Edward Kleinbard, Joint Committee on Taxation. A Reconsideration of Tax Expenditure Analysis.
4. February 5 – Amy Finkelstein, MIT Economics Department, EZ-Tax: Tax Salience and Tax Rates.
5. February 12 – Dorothy Brown, Emory Law School.
6. February 19 – Yoram Margalioth, Tel Aviv University Law School and NYU Law School.
7. February 26 – Leslie McCall, Northwestern University Sociology Department.
8. March 5 – Michael Doran, University of Virginia Law School.
9. March 12 – David Duff, University of Toronto Law School.
10. March 26 – Emmanuel Saez, Berkeley Economics Department. Details Matter: The Impact of Presentation and Information on the Take-Up of Financial Incentives for Retirement Saving.
11. April 2 – Lily Batchelder, NYU Law School.
12. April 9 – Mihir Desai, Harvard Business School and NYU Law School.
13. April 16 – Mitchell Kane, NYU Law School.
14. April 23 – Thomas Brennan, Northwestern Law School.

Campaigns as a political institution

Presidential campaigns are supposed to provide information so people can make intelligent choices. Partly from the candidates' announced intentions, and the rest from what we can discern about character, temperament, and intellect.

I've had my doubts sometimes about how well campaigns work, in an age of over-the-top media manipulation and contrived narratives, to do what they are supposed to. But can anyone doubt that the McCain campaign has been astonishingly revealing about what an erratic, lunatic child he is?

I was told before the campaign by Republicans who know McCain personally that he is more of a child than an adult, and that he is temperamentally unsuited to be president. Some of the people who have told me this said they couldn't support him, others were doing so anyway and perhaps even found it endearing (the childishness, not the temper).

But can anyone doubt now that he is utterly unsuited to be president? Even the National Review Online and the Wall Street Journal are raising their eyebrows about his latest stunt.

Wednesday, September 24, 2008

Case study in how bitter political fights destroy social capital

I've been thinking a lot lately about Rick Perlstein's Nixonland, which I read and enjoyed while on vacation this summer. While much of it is about the eponymous Trickster, a perennial favorite topic of mine, it's really mainly about a broader trend in our society that Nixon was brilliant and innovative at exploiting but that really goes way beyond his direct influence (i.e., in large part he merely exemplifies its development). This is the bitter division of our country between left and right, or red states and blue states, or however one chooses to characterize it. If the two groups hate each other enough, they can get into escalating tit-for-tat cycles that destroy the social capital that they need to cooperate as well as compete. Cooperation is necessary, for example, in setting (1) mutually accepted rules of the road for political debate that limit how dishonest and destructive it is permitted to get, or (2) the groundwork for the long-term budget deal (with taxes going up and entitlements down) that is indispensable if we are going to forestall a U.S. fiscal collapse. In foreign policy as well, while the notion that politics should stop at the water's edge perhaps always was naive and overly restrictive of needed policy debate, we are in big trouble if foreign policy begins to be set primarily with an eye to its efficacy in bludgeoning or sidestepping the opposition, rather than to serve U.S. national interests.

I had all this in mind - not identifying bad guys, as some of the above may suggest, but lamenting the problem - when I read a blog entry from Brad DeLong describing the cancellation of an Obama versus McCain debate that was scheduled to take place tonight at Stanford, under the auspices of the Stanford Institute for Economic Policy Research (SIEPR). Apparently, Austan Goolsbee was supposed to debate Doug Holtz-Eakin. But then Kevin Hassett replaced Doug, and after that Brad replaced Austan, whereupon Kevin, at least according to Brad, called it off.

Hassett and DeLong have a feud, on which you can get Brad's side at the above link, going back to Kevin's coauthored book, Dow 36,000, which I suppose even Kevin would agree made a prediction that did not come to pass within the suggested time frame of 3 to 5 years after 1999. (Hassett then recouped intellectually with his interesting follow-up, Bubbleology.) But although academics can always squabble over nothing as well as something, or over analytical fine points as well as fundamental political issues, I find it hard to doubt that the great and angry divide in our country had a lot to do with the Hassett-DeLong falling-out.

As it happens, although I am obviously intellectually and politically in DeLong's camp rather than Hassett's, I am friends with Kevin (with whom I co-taught the NYU Tax Policy Colloquium for the first half of the winter 2008 semester) and don't really know Brad personally. Without pointing any fingers or saying anyone is wrong, or even definitively assuming that without the great political divide this wouldn't have happened, I must say it's not only too bad but seems to exemplify the broader problems I've been writing about from time to time in this blog, regarding where our country seems to be headed.

Country last

It's amusing that McCain apparently wants to avoid voting on the bailout, but is eager to have Democrats provide the votes to pass it so that he can then safely grandstand as the noble naysayer. (Details here.)

Having been shamed into a press conference, he's quoted as follows:

"This issue should be - and their vote should be determined in how we can resolve this crisis and get America going again," McCain said. "This is a huge crisis. We know, in the words of many experts and mine, this is the greatest financial crisis since World War II. So to somehow, for the Democrats to say that their vote is going to be gauged on my vote frankly doesn't do them a great deal of credit.

"Their first and only priority should be making sure this economy recovers and get back on our feet again," McCain said.

I guess it logically follows, if we define the decision as purely theirs, that they aren't "putting America first" unless they agree to commit political harikiri, and that he isn't harming the recovery (supposing it to depend on passage of a bailout package) by merely exploiting it politically afterwards. But that doesn't make his stance any less sleazy or destructive of the social and political capital that one needs for government to function adequately in a competitive political environment.

UPDATE: What a loon, with his crazy stunt of purporting to suspend his campaign. All he has to do is (as the Obama campaign apparently proposed to him) put his name on a joint statement by the two of them regarding what they'd consider an acceptable deal.

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

Good day

My cold or allergies receded, I was productive and am close to finishing my paper on generational equity/efficiency/political economy and the fiscal gap, the expanded Pavement reissue of Brighten the Corners was announced for mid-November, the Mets won while the Yankees were eliminated, and Paulson got some of the tough questioning that he deserves.

Could the bailout actually make money for the Treasury?

Republican Senator Norman Coleman apparently is arguing that it could.

Theoretically speaking, Coleman actually is potentially right. The deleveraging theory that I've mentioned in earlier posts suggests that assets may end up having market values well below fundamental value in a temporary squeeze where there simply isn't enough money on the "long" side to compete away the windfalls suggested by the spread.

If Warren Buffett, say, indicated that he wants to buy the same bad loans that Secretary Paulson is talking about (supposing that he had enough money), and was willing to pay more than current market value, I would figure that this was indeed happening, and that Buffett might be quite likely to do well.

However, there are several key institutional differences between the hypothetical Buffett scenario and the actual one. The Treasury isn't deciding to go in for any such reason, would have no incentive to execute its buying strategy from a profit-making standpoint (even where socially optimal), and would probably be unable to do it competently even if it tried. Obviously, making money is not exactly at the heart of its institutional skill set.

Hence I would predict huge losses to the taxpayers even though the undervalued-assets scenario is by no means silly. Reinforcing the argument that Treasury's outlays ought to be fully financed under the assumption that they will recover zero, and probably, insofar as arbitrary stated measures matter to political behavior, ought to be included in the budget deficit.

Monday, September 22, 2008

The Paulson Catch-22

While Paulson is generally well-regarded, we don't really know a great deal about him as a public official. From that standpoint, his demanding a close to zero-oversight blank check grant of authority, followed by his calling for a "clean" bill to forestall, not Congressional pork barrel attachments but meaningful oversight, is not encouraging.

Another way of putting it is that his seeking these unfettered powers lowers one's confidence that he should have such powers.

Sunday, September 21, 2008

More on the bailout plan

Imagine that it's January 2009, and that Treasury Secretary Phil Gramm has $700 billion to dole out as he likes to Wall Street companies claiming distress. Phrases that occur to me include Teapot Dome (or perhaps I should say Iraq reconstruction), crony capitalism, and great Republican Party fundraising tool.

UPDATE: Great column by U of Chicago economist Luigi Zingales on the bailout.

Understatement of the day

From Peter Goodman, "But Will It Work?" in today's NY Times, page A-1:

"Some question the prudence of adding [$700 billion] to the nation’s overall debt at a time when the Treasury relies on the largess of foreigners to cover the bills."

The best argument in favor of being so reckless is not an edifying one. If you are going to crash and burn no matter what, why not max out the credit cards first and have a really good time.

On a more serious note, the fact that absolutely no one is discussing financing this wildly expensive bailout is exemplary of why the U.S. is likely headed for a catastrophic fiscal collapse. The core problem is more political than economic. Changing course would be conceptually easy to do though painful in practice. But Republicans have succeeded in utterly banishing from public discourse the idea of a budget constraint. Apparently nothing needs to be paid for. A $2 trillion Iraqi war? Reason to cut taxes. An $18 trillion Medicare prescription drug benefit? No need for financing. And imagine what would happen politically today if Pelosi, Reid, or Obama pointed out that we need to pay for this bailout. They're not that brave, but frankly I don't blame them. Why fall on your sword if no one will listen anyway?

Enacting the bailout without financing is sheer insanity, but it's going to happen beyond a doubt. You may ask: Does it really make sense to increase taxes at a time when we're teetering on the brink of recession? The answer, I'd say, is that it makes perfect sense to announce the tax increase - just not to implement it yet. A tax increase to pay for the bailout, with a deferred implementation date (say, 2010 or 2011) would be stimulative if considered credible, since it would reward accelerating economic activity.

Friday, September 19, 2008

Thursday, September 18, 2008

Subsidizing the Yankees

A House sub-committee is holding hearings today on alleged improprieties in the use of tax-exempt bond financing to pay for the new Yankee Stadium. Not to put too fine a point on it, but highly questionable representations concerning site value seem to have been made in the IRS private letter ruling request, which found the financing eligible for tax-exempt treatment without its being subject to the dollar cap on issuance of private activity bonds.

As an aside, even if the site value claims were true and the ruling remains valid, the plan that the IRS was asked to approve appears to have been a sneaky end-run around the intent of the dollar cap for private activity bonds, possibly undermining important public accountability and transparency goals in the design of the tax subsidy (as suggested in testimony before the sub-committee by my NYU colleague Clayton Gillette).

My own belief is that the Yankees should be punitively taxed, not subsidized. Major league baseball has already taken constructive steps in this direction, but the federal government should get in on the action as well.

And (shedding light perhaps on my mood swings concerning the election?) I will not feel totally sure that at last, for the first time since 1993, there will be baseball playoffs without the Yankees, until they are mathematically eliminated. Until that happens, how sure can one really be?

War with Spain?

Sorry guys, but you're going to have to wait your turn in line. After Iran, Russia, China, Syria, and North Korea, we will see what we can do.

Accounting rules and the financial meltdown

Today's WSJ had an interesting, albeit not very clearly written, op-ed by Zachary Karabell blaming post-Enron accounting rules for helping create the AIG meltdown. Read in conjunction with the WSJ's front-page coverage of the AIG drama as a case study in "deleveraging," the story appears to be as follows. As we all know, financial institutions (like all other companies) dislike having to write down their assets on the books and have long resisted doing so even when value has declined. For a long time, they could. But post-Enron, the accounting rules were changed to require more write-downs to market value. This, in turn, then triggered a self-reinforcing cycle of write-downs triggering mandatory asset sales, triggering distress prices far below fundamental value, triggering more write-downs, triggering more mandatory asset sales, and so forth. (Apparently a story that Bernanke, among others, has endorsed.)

One part of the story is that whoever buys the assets at distress prices far below fundamental value ends up doing just great when the dust settles. In the more rational world of an economics textbook or model, all you need is two such prospective purchasers who are competing with each other, rather than colluding, to drive the price up to fundamental value and make this scenario impossible. But apparently there isn't enough liquidity and prospective demand for under-valued assets for this to happen, especially when the bowling pins start falling one after the other.

As an aside, this I gather was at play in the collapse of Long-Term Capital Management some years back. A credit crunch forced them to sell assets for way below fundamental value, leaving some very happy purchasers to clean up (but apparently there were too few of them to drive the prices back up, and perhaps there was even implicit collusion to all enjoy part of the good thing that was popping into their laps).

Anyway, all this can't and won't happen in textbook financial markets, but I gather it actually is happening out there in the world, even at this very moment. One of the issues it raises is what to do with the accounting rules, which play a triggering role in the self-reinforcing downturn.

Obviously we want financial accounting to report true value. The argument here is that true value is hard to identify when you have a temporarily low market value and a higher fundamental value, and when the market mechanisms (arbitrage, etc.) that are supposed to drive these together aren't currently operating.

Is the solution not to write down assets to market valuation when there's reason to think that fundamental value is actually higher? This might sound good to me if we had Olympian companies and accountants honestly and objectively trying to determine when the two have been temporarily driven apart. However, given managerial incentive problems, along perhaps with evidence that they try to ignore, rather than just publicly deny, downturns in the making, it doesn't sound very good either.

So let's call it an open question for now what if anything should be done from an accounting standpoint about the deleveraging scenario that is currently hitting the markets so hard.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

The AIG rescue

It may well have been the right decision, all things considered, but I must say I really don't like it. The obvious points are moral hazard plus the question of exactly what the government is going to do with the new asset in its portfolio.

Interesting point about this is that the decision was presumably made by Bernanke and Paulson. These are the rare Bush Administration appointees - Gates comes to mind as well - whom I personally would trust in these matters as much as the average appointee in, say, a Reagan, Bush Sr., Clinton, or Obama Administration. (Maybe more than the average, given the hacks that are likely to be appointed to some roles in any Administration - so let's say I trust Bernanke and Paulson as much as the average good appointee in a historically typical Administration.)

But even so, any appointee in such a position arguably has slightly skewed incentives. (I would as well if I were the officeholder.) While the catastrophic downside that you are trying to prevent (if serving at the Fed or in the Treasury) obviously does in fact matter enormously, it arguably matters a little more to you than it does socially. Given that your job is to prevent it, and that you will go down in history as a horrendous failure if it happens on your watch, the clear incentive structure is to err on the side of worsening moral hazard, rather than of taking a bit too large a chance of an economic meltdown.

Over time, then, one would expect too many rescues, and I fear that this may fit and feed into that scenario.

UPDATE: It's interesting to observe, though I'm not sure what to make of it yet, that the market fell more than 400 points today despite / because of / without being affected by the AIG rescue.

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

Behind the market meltdown

Why are these things happening on Wall Street, and what can we learn from them?

Legal and economic scholarship concerning markets and regulation are actually in the ballpark of understanding this, if not of developing bulletproof answers. During my early years in the legal academy (which I entered in 1987), market-based, anti-regulatory law and economics was sweeping all before it - on merit, based on the insights it was advancing and the defects in prior ways of thinking about the issues.

But the pendulum has decisively turned with the rise of behavioral law and economics plus a greater understanding of the range and importance of agency costs and asymmetric information problems. (An example, in his recent writing about the subprime market, is my NYU colleague Oren Bar-Gill.)

Unfortunately, the devastating law & economics critique of politics and government solutions proved to be wrong in only one sense - it was too optimistic (!). So what will come of all this is unclear, although one certainly could imagine regulatory responses (to help in the future, not with what we face at the moment) addressing the blizzard of bad subprime loans to people who didn't understand what they were doing, the unwitting use of securitization to magnify agency problems and misaligned incentives, etc.

Unfortunately, I anticipate government remaining indefinitely in the hands of people who rely on an outmoded version of free market ideology (outmoded in their invocation of it even though in fact it retains enormous force rightly applied) as a thin veneer over a conscious actual policy of organized piracy on behalf of friends and campaign contributors.

Monday, September 15, 2008

Call me crazy but ...

... I've pretty much decided to stop following the 2008 presidential campaign. My sentiments are the same as previously, and I will of course vote. But I am simply finding it too infuriating and distressing; I could use stronger words if I wanted to get back in the mood. Given how little I can actually do, I feel there simply are more constructive and enjoyable uses for my time than following the daily twists and turns.

I gave up on baseball right before the 2004 season when the Yankees got A-Rod. I figured it wasn't worth following if they just kept on getting everyone. I came back when the Red Sox miracle happened. Ready to repeat that chapter, but this time it's serious business not fun and games, and also I think the prognosis is pitch dark. UK law and public policy schools should feel free to contact me this November.

Fall of the titans

Lehman Brothers apparently was founded in 1850, and Merrill Lynch in 1914. The fall of these two titans - though Merrill Lynch is merely being sold, not liquidated - truly is an epochal event, symbolizing how high the metaphorical flood waters, no less than the literal ones in various hurricane zones, are rising these days.

Saturday, September 13, 2008

Something about McCain that I've been wondering about lately

Let's see: he's been violent in public, and he's called his wife a "c---" in public. What sort of behavior in private does that fit the profile for?

Campaign / budget update from the Tax Policy Center

According to the widely respected Tax Policy Center, analyzing the candidates' campaign platforms:

"The simple bottom line: under Senator Obama’s tax plan as described by his campaign advisors, the ten-year federal deficit (before spending cuts) would total nearly $5.9 trillion; a comparable total for Senator McCain’s tax plan is almost $7.4 trillion. Expanding each candidate’s plan to include proposals made in stump speeches yields ten-year deficit totals (again before spending cuts) of $5.4 trillion for Obama and almost $11 trillion for McCain."

Neither candidate's spending cuts are included due to a lack of specificity from both in saying what these would be.

On the spending side, I'd say the ten-year McCain total is several trillion dollars too low given the foreign military adventures he would engage in.

Friday, September 12, 2008

Krugman gets it 99 percent right

From his column today on the presidential campaign:

"T]he deceptive and dishonest 2000 Bush-Cheney campaign provided an all-too-revealing preview of things to come. In fact, my early suspicion that we were being misled about the threat from Iraq came from the way the political tactics being used to sell the war resembled the tactics that had earlier been used to sell the Bush tax cuts.

"And now the team that hopes to form the next administration is running a campaign that makes Bush-Cheney 2000 look like something out of a civics class. What does that say about how that team would run the country?

"What it says, I’d argue, is that the Obama campaign is wrong to suggest that a McCain-Palin administration would just be a continuation of Bush-Cheney. If the way John McCain and Sarah Palin are campaigning is any indication, it would be much, much worse."

To this I'd just add, among the key Bush personality traits that has shaped his presidency is the fact that he is a natural, lifelong bully. But he does not appear to be a violent bully to quite the same degree as McCain. That's a rather large consideration when one considers that, under the current U.S. government system as it actually operates, the president effectively has plenary and unilateral war-making powers, and has lately been claiming equally plenary and unilateral domestic national security powers.

Thursday, September 11, 2008

Out-of-print album watch

First Dennis Wilson's Pacific Ocean Blue came back into print a couple of months ago - a great and very sad listen (if rather 70s) that is packaged with the equally good aborted follow-up, Bambu.

On Tuesday, Tom Verlaine's Dreamtime is coming back into print, his second solo album after the (initial) break-up of Television. I have the old LP but have been waiting for this one for years.

The next one on my list would be the Feelies' Crazy Rhythms. Hard to imagine why that one is out of print when it still has a following.

Ten good things about John McCain

I've been a bit harsh on him at times, but here are 10 GOOD things about John McCain, the best I could think of:

1) He performed up to his ability in military school.

2) He never lies when his lips aren't moving.

3) He's been right, at one time or another, about most major domestic policy issues (since he's taken both sides).

4) He creates good jobs ... for lobbyists in his campaign.

5) You try making better decisions with as little time, care, and information as he uses.

6) While his tax plans would cost $7 trillion over the next ten years, he is hoping to make back 1 percent of that amount by reforming earmarks.

7) He's willing to share his POW story with us again and again and again and again, even though he hates talking about it.

8) So far as we know, he's only gotten into a couple of physical altercations with fellow members of Congress.

9) To forgive is divine, and he just hired the guy who slimed him in South Carolina in 2000.

10) There are probably a couple of vile names that he hasn't called his wife in front of witnesses.

Rosanne Altshuler becomes co-director of the Tax Policy Center

The Urban-Brookings Tax Policy Center just announced that, starting in January, Rosanne Altshuler will become its co-director, joining Len Burman and Bill Gale. This is great news on many levels. Rosanne, one of the best international tax economists in the country, is an incredibly thoughtful, careful, and creative scholar who has made important contributions and is at the forefront of thinking seriously and fair-mindedly (not a universal trait) about where U.S. international tax policy should go. She also has fantastic knowledge in multiple arenas, ranging from the empirical issues to understanding legal and institutional details. The only downside, a selfish one, is that we in the NYC tax policy community will regret seeing less of her.

9/11

Being in downtown NYC, I saw the whole thing happen and then lived through the crazy days that came after it. I will never forget the shock, rage, and fear of that period.

But by its seventh anniversary there's an even more hateful overlay. Now, 9/11 invokes in my memory above all:

1) "All right, you've covered your ass. You can go home now." (Bush to the CIA briefer in August 2001.)

2) My Pet Goat.

3) The instantaneous decision, made at the top but immediately embraced (and indeed anticipated) by the entire Republican establishment and base, to treat it as a wedge issue for political gain, rather than as a Pearl Harbor-like national focal point. Only people who hated their opponents and loved power more than they cared about anything else could have done such a thing. If there were a hell they would rot in it eternally for that alone.

Monday, September 08, 2008

When will the U.S. default?

For my current work in progress, "The Long-Term U.S. Fiscal Gap: Is the Main Problem Generational Inequity?," I recently took a look at the question of how fast, under current budget scenarios, the U.S. debt-to-GDP ratio would explode. The sequence is potentially interesting because capital markets, in determining when U.S. public debt should cease to be considered a safe investment, may look only so far ahead, given not just myopia (which need not be posited here), but (a) the fact that the real issue is credibility, which may be affected by the timing of the exploding debt problem, and (b) the unpredictable psychology of bubble markets.

Luckily for me - as I do theoretical not empirical work - the General Accounting Office recently did a long-term simulation of the projected U.S. debt-to-GDP ratio over time under present policy. It's available via their public website (details available to the curious who contact me if they can't find it themselves).

More specifically, the GAO did 2 simulations, one under the CBO baseline and the other adjusting it to be more realistic (e.g., expiring tax cuts are extended for a while, discretionary spending grows with the economy & population). The CBO baseline is plainly ridiculous - for example, it shows massive budget surpluses from 2010 to 2020 that no one expects will actually happen - so I present below only the figures for the alternative simulation.

YEAR - - - - - U.S. PUBLIC DEBT / GDP (as %)
2008 - - - - - - - - - 37.1
2010 - - - - - - - - - 38.7
2015 - - - - - - - - - 47.1
2020 - - - - - - - - - 60.8
2025 - - - - - - - - - 80.7
2030 - - - - - - - - - 109.2
2035 - - - - - - - - - 145.6
2040 - - - - - - - - - 188.4
2045 - - - - - - - - - 236.6
2050 - - - - - - - - - 290.1
2055 - - - - - - - - - 348.5
2060 - - - - - - - - - 412.0
2065 - - - - - - - - - 480.3
2070 - - - - - - - - - 553.8
2075 - - - - - - - - - 632.0
2080 - - - - - - - - - 714.8

As a bit of background, the all-time U.S. high debt to GDP ratio was 109 percent, right at the end of World War II. BUT - in 1945 it was clear to the world that, with peacetime rapidly approaching, annual budget deficits and thus new debt issuances were about to plunge. This time around, the picture would be radically different absent a credible prospect of voluntary budget reform.

Some people may conclude from this that we still have a bit of time. Maybe so, maybe not, because financial markets can be very forward-looking and even, say, the Chinese government might be able to precipitate the plunge right now (which is not to say they'd ever rationally want to do this).

Sunday, September 07, 2008

Open empirical question

Brendan Nyhan suggests that liberal blogger Josh Marshall is guilty of a "smear" when he compares Guiliani's speech at the recently concluded RNC convention to a speech by Josef Goebbels. Nyhan notes that "casual Nazi analogies demean and cheapen the discourse -- it's an easy way to active a series of unflattering associations and attach them to a public figure that you don't like." He then compares Marshall's Nazi analogies to Bush's arguably comparing the Democrats to Vietnamese Communists in his video address to the convention.

Here's my problem with so rapidly dismissing the left side of this, which is comparing the current Republicans to Nazis or fascists. I regard it as a genuinely open empirical question how far these guys are willing to go to destroy American democracy. For my money, the discourse at the RNC convention truly was Nazi or fascist-style: demeaning opponents as less than fully human or at least not American, militarism, outrageously over the top lying (Palin on the Bridge to Nowhere, Guiliani denouncing cosmopolitans, Romney denouncing Eastern elites), claiming that only people from small towns are real Americans, etc. Then there's the executive authoritarianism, the claims the president can lock up anyone indefinitely, lying to get us into wars, government secrecy for everything (including indefensible legal opinions embracing torture), the use of torture itself when its intelligence payoff has pretty much been proven to be negative, complete politicization of the executive branch, use of the Justice Department to throw political foes such as Don Siegelman in jail, and repeated, systematic attempts to intimidate the media and prevent it from questioning even demonstrably false claims (whether about Guanatanamo or Palin's earmark record), etc.

I feel they are destroying civil society and the rule of law, and I honestly don't know how far they would go. Explicit dictatorship? Jailing of the opposition? Reichstag fire style fake terror attacks? (Bush and Cheney have both been quoted considering the equivalent in foreign affairs to create casus bellis with Iraq and Iran.) I don't think that leading Republicans themselves know what they would do or where they are headed beyond the next news cycle, but that doesn't mean that they aren't, via their incentives and inclinations and the pressure of events, headed somewhere very nasty.

At this point, I feel there are reasonable arguments to be made on both sides of this - yes, they are something new in American politics and there really is no limit to how far they would go; or no, it's pretty much still business as usual and neither politics nor government have ever been pretty.

But Nyhan is guilty of simply assuming the no side here. He might be right, but at this point I feel we genuinely don't know.

Wednesday, September 03, 2008

Siberia sounds toasty by comparison

I gather from a Michael Isikoff blog on the Newsweek site that Doug Holtz-Eakin has been posted from the McCain campaign over to Sarah Palin as director of her domestic policy operation (such as it is).

Wow - what a reward to Doug for having endangered his (previously justifiably high) reputation for all these months by carrying water for the campaign's wildly irresponsible tax and budget policies.

New wine in old bottles

I find the newly released Byrne-Eno album quite charming, even delightful, but am going to pass on the new Brian Wilson (odds seem high against its actually being much good).

Tuesday, September 02, 2008

Call me old-fashioned, but ...

.. while I think chest-beating invocations of patriotism can be over-done, I still have this crazy belief that elected U.S. national leaders should be, well, pro-U.S., rather than Alaskan nationalists.

Thursday, August 28, 2008

Changing seasons

The signs are everywhere. Fresh apricots are no longer available at the local farmers' markets. The weather is less hot and more comfortable - a fact that is nonetheless dispiriting (though not as much as the departed apricots) because one knows where it is headed. And I have taught my first class, which I thought went fine although it always takes a few sessions to establish rapport and rhythm.

Sunday, August 24, 2008

Back in NYC

I spent the last few days at an academic conference in Woodstock, VT. Best way to describe the local ambience is to note that even a gas station convenience store had microbrewery wheat beers and fresh whole-grain breads from a local gourmet bakery. I forgot to check for the whimsically named local brand of fresh dark-roasted whole coffee beans, but maybe it was behind the chai.

Thursday, August 21, 2008

Big thought for the day

Getting older is like managing the retreat of an Army unit. You know you have to give ground and will eventually lose everything. But in the meantime you want to retreat as slowly as possible, keeping it orderly and preventing a rout. Anywhere you can stand and fight for a while you should if the odds are good enough.

Hence my giving up on squash a year ago but deciding to keep up tennis. After ten months of being unable to play a match I am back on the courts competing, but it takes a lot of exercise, stretching, and rehab to keep the odds of continuing (for decades?) reasonably good.


Then there is our eldest cat Shadow (age 17), for whom the retreat is considerably more advanced. Having already lost his teeth and developed an over-active thyroid that, despite surgery (!), still over-produces enough hormones to kill him if we weren't giving him a pill twice daily plus special food, he now appears to have developed chronic kidney disease. This requires injecting him in the back with fluids once a day, at least for now, I gather simply to slow the ongoing process that might take as long as a couple of years (though then again it might be a lot less). And it requires a change in diet that, I gather, involves retreat on managing the thyroid problem as the kidney issue is more acute.

Despite all the extremely nice cats in the world you can find in shelters that evidently are not finding homes, Shadow is about as good an argument for animal cloning as I have yet met. We adopted him when the men's clothing store he lived in was closing and he started following me around the store when I came back to pick up my garments. Placid, mellow, sweet-tempered, loves people, likes other cats - he makes me proud to be a fellow mammal.

Here he is enjoying the sun, which he may not get to do for much longer.

Monday, August 18, 2008

Krugman on the U.S. corporate tax rate

There's been a lot of focus in tax policy circles on the contention that the U.S. corporate rate is too high, leading to one or more of the following claimed ill effects: (1) competitive disadvantage to U.S. companies abroad (which might or might not affect U.S. national welfare), (2) reduced investment in the U.S., including the inbound, and/or (3) the shifting of reported taxable income, and thus tax revenues, out of the U.S. to other countries with lower rates. It's clear that the U.S. corporate rate, 35%, is these days a bit of an outlier on the high side.

But is that the number that matters? Paul Krugman thinks not:

"Now, the thing you have to realize about corporate taxes is that the statutory rate — the rate you pay after [being] allowed deductions and all that — means very little. That’s because corporations have lots of potential deductions — and can hire the very best accountants to find them, and lawyers to justify them. So any time you see a table that compares the nasty 35% US rate with other countries, you know you’re being snowed.

"A much better indicator is the amount of taxes corporations actually pay. From OECD data (behind a paywall, I think, unfortunately), I get the following for percentage of GDP paid in corporate taxes in some major economies, in 2005:

Canada 3.5
US 3.1
Japan 4.3
France 2.8
Germany 1.7
UK 3.4."

Point taken about the statutory rate standing alone. But that's not to say that Krugman's preferred indicator is any better, or indeed as good. For starters, one has to ask how much economic activity in a given country, relative to GDP, is run through corporations, rather than other forms. Does the U.S. have a greater tendency for business activity to run through partnerships, etcetera? In other words, the correct denominator of the fraction is not necessarily national GDP. For a first cut it's corporate economic activity, though even that isn't quite right because you have to think about the consequences of shifting activity around into or out of corporate solution (and how that's taxed).

Not to mention that the second, shareholder level of tax is important to the assessment as well, although that raises further complications that I won't get into here.

Also, if we are mainly concerned about incentive effects, efficiency, and net U.S. national economic welfare, rather than distribution - and I think that is the main long-term issue here, as I'll explain in a moment - then it's not the average but the marginal U.S. corporate tax rate that we care about. So, insofar as companies can play games to save some tax inframarginally, but can't get to zero or boost up their sheltering when they make more profits, it's possible that they would be paying closer to 35% than to their average rates at the margin. I'm not asserting this, but merely noting that it's possible and that the data Krugman cites don't address it.

But is this a distribution issue, not one of efficiency? Krugman presumably thinks so, and he has a point. Taking as given the level of corporate investment et al, which reflects expectations about effective tax rates, if we then in practice lower or raise the overall corporate effective rate the winners or losers are probably corporate shareholders, who on average are relatively affluent. This is the transition incidence of an unanticipated change in the level of the corporate tax. Thus, corporate shareholders would presumably win (all else equal) from lowering the corporate rate to 25%, given that such a change (though being debated) presumably is not, at this point, considered anywhere close to certain. But if we are talking about a stable equilibrium level of effective taxation of corporate income, then it all depends on the incidence of this tax - which economists increasingly believe, in the open economy era, falls largely on labor rather than capital. (See my forthcoming corporate tax book with the Urban Institute Press, "The U.S. Corporate Tax - What Is It and Where Is It Headed?" - due out in early 2009 - for a fuller discussion of these points.)

Friday, August 15, 2008

If John McCain had written John Lennon's songs

"All we are saying is give war a chance."

"War is the answer
You've gotta let it, you've gotta let it grow."

"War is real, real is war
War is feeling, feeling war
War is wanting to make war."

"Peace is over, if you want it
Peace is over now."

Thursday, August 14, 2008

Guiltier pleasures

OK, I admit it. I have been watching and enjoying Project Runway lately. It's especially helpful when I need to get through a bunch of exercises designed to prevent recurrence of any of the six main injuries that have cost me substantial tennis-playing time in recent years. But with the convenience of Tivo I would probably watch it for a season or two in any event.

This past Monday night, however, I sank to depths previously unimagined by watching the Bravo reality show "Date My Ex - Jo and Slade" while running through my exercises. (OK, let's be honest - I've actually tuned in, for half to three-quarters of the program, on each of the last 2 Mondays.)

For sleaziness, stupidity, triviality, excruciating vapidity, and idiotic contrivance, "Date My Ex - Jo and Slade" is truly off the charts. It's pathetic. I don't see how any self-respecting, even moderately intelligent and discriminating person could watch it.

But self-respect is overrated, isn't it? And next Monday is already approaching.

Tempest in a teapot

Speaker Pelosi is saying that the GAO report that came out this week, indicating that two-thirds of all U.S. corporations pay no tax at all, "highlights the need to revisit tax reform to ensure that U.S. companies pay their fair share of taxes."

Now, I certainly agree about the need for tax reform, and for addressing corporate-level tax avoidance, but not based on the GAO report, which was truly a non-event. The fact that lots of corporations pay no taxes means next to nothing when lots of them may be small companies without significant profits. Even the fact that, according to the report, 25% of fairly large companies paid no taxes, while a bit more interesting, does not immediately make one excited given that we have recently had a bit of a recession.

The finding in the report that foreign-controlled U.S. corporations report lower profits than those that are U.S. owned is a bit interesting, and suggests (as the report notes) that the foreign companies may be using transfer pricing to shift profits out of the U.S. (Or perhaps they haven't been doing well here lately.) But I believe the comparison in the report is to U.S.-owned companies generally. A more interesting comparison would be to U.S.-owned multinationals, since they have roughly the same transfer pricing incentives and opportunities as the foreign firms. In other words, the key here may be multinational enterprise, not whether a company is treated as a U.S. resident or not.

Readers should also keep in mind that, insofar as transfer pricing is hurting U.S. revenues, one of its possible policy implications is that the U.S. corporate tax rate should be lower so the incentive to engage in it will be less. Tougher enforcement is also an option, but transfer pricing is notoriously difficult to do right - since there is no underlying there there - and it also leads to very costly compliance and litigation.

So let's have tax reform by all means (not that I expect it by any means), but intellectual honesty suggests not basing it on the GAO report's supposed findings.

Furman and Goolsbee on Obama's and McCain's tax and budget policies

In today's WSJ, lead Obama economists Jason Furman and Austan Goolsbee continue to use the Bush budget baseline (for reasons I understand but regret).

As readers can tell from my past posts, I disagree with plenty of what Obama is proposing, partly though not wholly because I have the luxury of not running a contested political campaign. But I certainly agree with the following paragraph in which Furman and Goolsbee address McCain:

"The McCain plan represents Bush economics on steroids. It has $3.4 trillion more in tax cuts than President Bush is proposing, largely directed at corporations and the most affluent. Sen. McCain would implement these cuts without proposing any meaningful steps to simplify taxes or eliminate distortions and loopholes. In addition, Sen. McCain has floated over $1 trillion in new spending increases but barely any specific spending cuts."

Okay, presumably unlike Obama, Furman, and Goolsbee, I would support McCain's proposed cut in the corporate tax rate to 25% if it were fully financed and accompanied by measures shifting more tax collection to owners and especially owner-employees. (See here, for example.)

But the most interesting bit for me in the above paragraph was the $1 trillion figure they offer concerning spending increases that McCain has floated. I am sure they have something specific in mind to back this up, although possibly the figure could be contested (most likely, on the ground that McCain shouldn't be treated as actually meaning what he said on the campaign trail). But the number surely does not include the costs for all the overseas military activity that McCain is eagerly planning. That stuff can add up (e.g., $2 trillion so far in Iraq).

McCain economist Doug Holtz-Eakin attempts to defend his side's relative budgetary integrity on the ground that they will cut spending vastly compared to the present path or Obama. Color me extremely skeptical. Taking into account the extensive military adventures that McCain, even if not actively planning, will nonetheless find himself irresistibly drawn into starting, the actual balance on projected spending may lie sharply in Obama's favor.

Tuesday, August 12, 2008

McCain betting odds

In light of the ignorant bellicosity that he's once again trumpeted in the face of the Georgia crisis (see here), I'd posit the following, if he becomes president:

--Over/under for the likely average number of wars we'll be engaged in at any given time during his presidency: 2.5.

--Likelihood of his using nuclear weapons: .3.

On the former, note that we're at 2 wars already (which he is reluctant to reduce to 1) and that he appears to want to fight Russia, China, Iran, and presumably Syria and North Korea.

On the latter, note that Cheney, his only Bush Administration near-twin for bellicosity (!!), reportedly pushed internally for the use of nuclear weapons against Iran. I wonder if the probability I offer is way too low.

The state we're in

The Washington Post has an article today entitled "Obama Tax Plan Would Balloon Deficit, Analysis Finds."

The key point: while Obama (with indisputable accuracy) denounces Bush's "reckless" economic policies that are "mortgaging our children's future on a mountain of debt," he is himself proposing tax changes that would add $3.4 trillion to the national debt, including interest, by 2018, as compared to present law (which has all those Bush tax cuts expiring after 2010).

So that it won't look so bad, Obama uses Bush's fiscal policy baseline, in which it is assumed that all of the tax cuts will be extended (and various other fiscally adverse policies adopted as well). Under the Bush baseline, Obama offers middle class tax cuts without increasing the national debt. (I.e., he finances his tax cuts by scaling back the ones Bush and McCain want to extend.)

Len Burman puts it well in the Post article: "Obama has criticized Bush for his fiscal irresponsibility, and now he's using Bush's baseline as a yardstick by which to measure fiscal responsibility."

Jason Furman, who is running Obama's economics shop and who obviously understands all this, defends using the Bush baseline as part of drawing a clear distinction with McCain, who plans to go way beyond the insane Bush baseline and add more than $5 trillion to the national debt over the next ten years.

And this in turn helps to show why the U.S. political and fiscal system are in such bad shape. As things stand, Obama is proposing unsustainable tax cuts (relative to the present law baseline). Yet he is being (a) trillions of dollars less irresponsible than McCain, and (b) attacked by the McCain campaign, based on repeated and shameless lies, as someone who is proposing to increase people's taxes. (The ads about the tax increase for people earning $42,000, recently exposed by independent fact checkers as having "multiple false and misleading claims," are simply par for the course.) So I'd have to agree that, with the bogus baseline and unsustainable tax cuts, Obama is nonetheless being about as fiscally responsible as it is politically feasible to be in a closely contested presidential campaign.

Gresham's law applies to baselines as well as money - the bad ones drive out the good. In the soundbite world of contemporary politics, you simply can't hold yourself to a more reasonable baseline and then try to explain the difference. No one understands, and no one cares.

This is why we are headed off a cliff - not because the fiscal situation is so bad (although it ain't good), but rather because the contemporary political environment makes rational problem-solving impossible.

And our system's pervasive and growing political failure is not limited to budgetary politics. Think gas prices and the McCain campaign's wildly dishonest use of the drilling "issue."

Not to sound old-fashioned, but to me our country's most serious problem is the decline of civic virtue, mainly on the right (where for many it's been replaced by Leninist ethics). The press and the public can't monitor Rove-style dishonesty and resulting destruction of rational dialogue about problems - you need people on each side who are reciprocally willing to limit it through a kind of cooperative quid pro quo. Instead we get chicken games that may end like the one in Rebel Without a Cause (only it will be the audience that goes off the cliff, not one of the drivers).

Monday, August 04, 2008

Right charge, wrong example

Obama is running an ad attacking McCain for proposing a $4 billion tax break for oil companies right when their profits are way up, and noting that McCain has just gotten $2 million in oil company executive campaign contributions.

I gather the $4 billion is computed simply by applying to the oil companies McCain's proposal to lower the corporate tax rate to 25 percent.

The actual story here is that McCain and/or the RNC got a huge flood of oil company campaign contributions (e.g., from 10 Hess Company executives each of whom gave the max) in the almost immediate aftermath of his flip-flop on offshore oil drilling. No doubt they are also grateful for his gas tax holiday demagoguery given the likelihood that they would pocket the benefit. But in fact their share of the corporate rate cut is not from a proposal that was aimed at them; rather, it's one applying more generally.

Presumably the ad uses the $4 billion figure taken from the general corporate rate cut proposal because the other items are harder to explain non-distractingly in a 30-second narrative.

A bit of an irony here for me is that I personally would favor the corporate rate cut if (a) fully financed so that it does not increase the fiscal gap and (b) accompanied by rules limiting the use of the corporate form as a low-rate tax shelter for high-income individuals (e.g., use of "reasonable compensation" rules to prevent under-payment of salary for tax purposes to high-bracket owner-employees). And I suspect I would oppose Obama's proposed windfall profits tax for oil companies, which the commercial also touts, if I knew more of the details - these tend to be gimmicky and not very good tax instruments.

The basic point of the commercial is important and correct, however, even if its policy content is questionable. McCain is in the tank (so to speak) for the oil companies in ways that lead him to make consciously dishonest proposals to benefit them, e.g., rationalizing the offshore oil drilling in terms of the price of gas when its effect on prices would be so deferred and trivial. And this is a relevant character issue, not just a policy issue.

Sunday, August 03, 2008

David Gergen says the obvious

Gergen, not exactly a radical leftist, apparently said on TV this weekend: "When McCain's camp calls Obama "The Messiah" and "The One", he's really calling him "uppity." I'm from the South, and we understand what that means. That's code."

I'm not from the South and yet it's been totally obvious to me. This is the whole point of the "celebrity" dig. Why would McCain consider this a telling criticism, when we live in a celebrity culture, and when McCain himself, self-evidently, has long been a celebrity as well? Because, coming from him, it isn't "uppity." Indeed, not even "presumptuous" (another absurdly thin coding for the racial epithet).

Thursday, July 31, 2008

Like Scottie in Hitchcock's Vertigo

That's a bit how I feel watching it happen yet again - the quadrennial attack on the Democratic presidential candidate as "elitist" and "out of touch," launched by Rove & his disciples on behalf of an arrogant multi-millionaire who wants to play War Emperor while handing huge and unsustainable tax breaks to very rich people. And the Democrat, meanwhile, ineffectually ignores the attacks and fails to launch any of the devastating counter-attacks that would seem to be clearly available, thinking mistakenly that playing nice and being less blatantly dishonest will be rewarded.

Maybe it'll end differently this time. But in Vertigo it didn't.

Wednesday, July 30, 2008

The bogus tax-spending distinction strikes again

While McCain tours the land insisting that Obama plans to raise taxes, his chief economic advisor (leaving aside the buffoonish Phil Gramm), Doug Holtz-Eakin, has admitted publicly that Obama actually plans to cut taxes on balance. Details here.

The ground for finding a net tax cut is that Obama's healthcare package would make heavy use of targeted tax benefits to increase insurance coverage and the like.

Holtz-Eakin, by the way, is using the net tax cut point to argue that Obama's overall policies are fiscally irresponsible. This of course is true enough, albeit comical coming from someone who works in a campaign that is calling for $5.7 trillion of tax cuts over ten years with virtually no significant and credible offsets. (McCain will presumably nonetheless keep on saying that Obama is raising taxes, since the truth has certainly been no constraint for him over the last few weeks of the campaign.)

Anyway, back to the net tax cut point. As I show at some length (but I hope reasonably entertainingly) in my recently published fiscal language book, people treat the taxes versus spending distinction as if it were substantively meaningful (e.g., regarding the size of government or some such thing) even though in fact it is pure form.

A program that is substantively equivalent to targeted tax benefits can always, at least in theory, be provided through direct spending. My favorite example, which I owe to the late economist David Bradford, is reducing both taxes and spending by $50 billion, without substantively changing anything whatsoever, by replacing $50 billion of military spending with a $50 billion "weapons supplier tax credit," which results in the government's getting exactly the same weapons as before while everyone in the society ends up with exactly the same money and incentives.

Whatever the reasons for and against using the tax system to deliver healthcare benefits, it is pretty silly to have the computation of whether one is "cutting taxes' or not depend on it. Or more precisely, it's pretty silly to think that the "cutting taxes" meme means anything until we have dug down into the details a bit more.

One possible takeaway: Obama is increasing the government's role in the economy despite styling these things "tax cuts." True enough, perhaps, although the healthcare sector of the economy is too much of a mess for this necessarily to be bad even if one generally likes less government intervention. (One key problem in the healthcare sector is its mix of generous subsidies with private profit motives, arguably leading to worse incentives than those from either a purely public or purely private system.)

But then again, unsustainable tax cuts like McCain's don't make the government smaller either, even if they take the form of reduced marginal rates and the like, as I also explain in my book.

Tuesday, July 29, 2008

The actual 2009 budget deficit may exceed $900 billion

Despite my discomfort with using the annual budget deficit as a measure of long-term fiscal problems, I feel the need to say a bit more about the bogus $482 billion number that the Bush Administration has succeeded (through dishonest accounting) in putting into all the headlines. Absolutely everyone seems to be using this number. And yet:

1) It "includes only $70 billion for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, which could cost three times that much." So perhaps we should add as much as $140 billion for this.

2) It ignores both Congress's recent reversal of the cut in Medicare reimbursements to doctors and the recent enactment of a massive housing bill. I don't have revenue estimates for these in front of me (I will add them in an update if anyone is kind enough to give me a link), but we definitely are not talking small potatoes,

3) It uses the usual rosy scenario economic forecasting tricks, such as predicting an economic growth rate of 2.2 percent whereas many private sector economists are predicting only 1.7 percent.

Former Bush Treasury Secretary O'Neill is quoted in the above-linked article as saying that the real number is "upward of $500 billion and counting. It's a mind-boggling number." As much as $650 billion, anyone? Under the above, I don't see why not.

Even this, however, is not the best annual deficit number that one can use. In less dishonest times, government officials used the on-budget deficit rather than the unified budget deficit, so they would avoid taking credit for current cash flow surpluses in Social Security given its long-term financing shortfall. The exact same principle suggests excluding current cash-flow surpluses for all ostensibly self-financing government retirement programs (e.g., Medicare part A) that are in long-term deficit.

According to a recent article by Alan Auerbach, Jason Furman, and Bill Gale, excluding these programs would increase the then-estimated 2008 budget deficit by $260 billion (from $357 billion to $617 billion). Again, I don't have the exactly comparable 2009 projected numbers. But it's pretty obvious that adding anything like this to the otherwise corrected but still "unified" 2009 deficit number is likely to leave us well north of $800 billion, and very possibly as high as $900 billion.

Monday, July 28, 2008

Record budget deficit

Bush Administration officials now say this year's budget deficit will set an all-time record by standing at $490 billion, as compared to the budget surplus of $128 billion that Bush inherited.

News media are using the $490 billion number even though it apparently excludes $80 billion of Iraq and Afghanistan war spending.

I can't imagine why the Bush Administration feels compelled to admit there is any deficit at all. If they ignored a further $500 billion of spending - and I don't see why they wouldn't, given that they ignore the war spending without any shred of a rationale or excuse - they could accurately note that there's otherwise a $10 billion surplus, and enjoy the nice headlines from that.

UPDATE: Okay, calling it a record is admittedly dubious given that more meaningful comparisons between years would (a) adjust the nominal deficit for inflation, and (b) report it as a percentage of GDP rather than an absolute dollar amount. But then again, given the deficit's defects as a measure purely of current year cash flows, paying it any attention in lieu of focusing on longer-term measures (such as the fiscal gap) paints too rosy a picture.

Sunday, July 27, 2008

No comment necessary

McCain, on ABC's This Week with George Stephanopoulos, explaining why, contrary to what all the economists say, a gas tax holiday would be passed on to consumers after all:

McCain: ... we wouldn't let it happen. We wouldn't let it happen. Americans wouldn't let them absorb that.

Stephanopoulos: How would you prevent that?

McCain: We would make them shamed into it. We of course know how to...American public opinion. And we would penalize them if necessary. But they wouldn't. They would pass it along.

Monday, July 21, 2008

No new stimulus bill?

Budget expert Stan Collender predicts that there will be no new stimulus bill this year, despite politicians' anxiety about being blamed by voters for the continuing economic slowdown, on the very shrewd ground that pursuing further fiscal stimulus might not quite make sense right now either for the Republicans or the Democrats.

I must confess that this is a relief to me (assuming Stan is right), even though I recognize that the macro-economy is continuing to sputter badly. If we generalize the question from whether well-done stimulus might make sense today to that of whether a political rule in favor of doing it is efficacious on balance, I think the better view remains, pretty clearly, no. This was indeed the consensus of the political and policymaking world until it was reversed by Bill Clinton in the 1992 election ("It's the economy, stupid."). After that, no one on either side of the aisle wanted to risk being cast in the public role that George H.W. Bush ended up playing in the 1992 drama. But to me, the fact that Clinton revised the optimal political calculation does not mean that he revised the optimal policymaking calculation, as indeed we saw anew when George W. Bush misleadingly cast the 2003 tax cuts as fiscal stimulus.

Let the Fed handle it, I say, not because it necessarily can, and not because better-functioning political branches of government couldn't chip in as well through counter-cyclical fiscal policy, but because, as Donald Rumsfeld might have put it, we can only go into battle with the political branches that we actually have.

Sunday, July 20, 2008

Rewrite hell

The heading of this post is a great overstatement, but I do indeed find myself working these days on revisions to forthcoming publications rather than new work. I have minor revisions to make (but they can still take a bit of time) both to my tax & accounting article that is forthcoming in the Georgetown Law Journal, and to my forthcoming Urban Institute Press book, "The Corporate Tax: What Is It, and Where Is It Headed?"

David Bradford once said that, if you polish a forthcoming piece to the point of perfection, that proves you have misallocated your time, since the marginal value of the last increments of improvement are surely less than the marginal value you could have created by doing something creative and new. I tend to agree (and impatience pushes me in the same direction), though it is also true that when you publish something, it is Part of Your Permanent Record that will follow you for the rest of your life.

Meanwhile, I will be teaching Tax I at NYU in just over 5 weeks, and gather that I have 98 registered students. Hoping it will be fun for one and all (or at least for the great majority), but certainly not an intimate-sized group.

Is McCain really the author of the "surge"?

In a word, no. During the pre-surge years, his subsequent mythmaking nowithstanding, he spent at least 80 percent of the time totally supporting Bush and Rumsfeld and saying that the war was going great. He supported the surge when it came due to a simple kneejerk rule that he follows at all times: among all the politically credible options that are on the table in U.S. foreign policy debate, he always supports the most hawkish and pro-war alternative out there. Putting more soldiers in Iraq fit this simple formula, so he supported it.

Some may still recall that Democrats were saying for years that Bush and Rumsfeld had put too few troops in Iraq given that we were there. But that has been effaced from memory like the war with Eurasia in 1984 once they've switched to fighting Eastasia.

Interesting how Maliki's endorsement of Obama's Iraq plan is not even considered newsworthy in the major U.S. papers. Apparently it didn't happen.

Sorry, I will get back to my fiscal policy topics but every now and then I need to blow off a little steam.

Friday, July 18, 2008

McCain supports longer gas tax holiday!

Yes, three months is no longer enough, and he now wants to make the gas tax holiday longer.

I still don't think he's going far enough. Why not propose generous gas subsidies? Or at least financial rewards for owning a gas guzzler, since he specifically emphasizes the plight of "low income Americans that [sic] are driving the oldest automobiles."

Funny how the one big case in which McCain emphasizes helping low-income Americans is via a proposal that would not actually do so, given the general consensus among economists that the gas tax holiday would not actually lower prices at the pump.

Although then again, it's not even a proposal - rather, it's just a Kabuki gesture - given that he is not actually proposing legislation to implement it. Last I checked, he was still a Senator.

Next stop, Sundance?

I just finished taping a couple of hours with some documentary filmmakers who are bravely preparing a feature on tax reform and the problems with the tax system. They hope to have their film in distribution later this year. It's to be called "An Inconvenient Tax," and you can find out more about it here and here.

Thursday, July 17, 2008

Bruce Bartlett on McCain vs. Obama

Bruce Bartlett, a leading conservative critic of contemporary Republicans who have hijacked and besmirched the conservative label, argues on the following grounds that McCain's and Obama's tax policies would be less different than one might think. To preview my response, it would be a better world if Bruce were right in his predictions about what they would do but I'm not convinced that he is right. Anyway, he says the following:

"As for taxes, the next president is probably going to raise them regardless of who is elected. That is because our nation’s fiscal problems are becoming too pressing to ignore. A key reason is that the first members of the baby boom generation will turn 65 during the next administration, qualifying for Medicare and, at 66, for Social Security. Sooner rather than later, fiscal reality will force action on the budget. And with the political impossibility of cutting spending by enough to matter, especially with Democratic control of Congress, the default position will necessarily be higher taxes.

"To be sure, McCain and Obama will raise taxes differently, and that is not unimportant. But the simple idea that Obama will raise taxes and McCain will cut them is nonsense. Every serious budget analyst knows this, even if McCain insists that he can continue all the Bush tax cuts, cut taxes by hundreds of billions of dollars additionally, and still balance the budget. That is impossible. It’s also worth remembering that McCain has never been a stalwart tax cutter, having opposed the Bush tax cuts in 2001 and 2003 on the grounds that they were giveaways to the rich."

This is entirely, indeed verging on indisputably correct if we posit that the next president will follow policies that are not entirely insane. But insanity can prevail for a long time, so I disagree that McCain will raise taxes simply because the fiscal situation makes doing so unavoidable in the long run.

Obviously he will not balance the budget. But until the capital markets go haywire (i.e., the U.S. can no longer sell bonds without paying a huge interest rate premium based on investors' concern about default, whether explicit via non-payment or implicit via hyper-inflation), absolutely nothing stops us from following a fiscal policy that is crazy and unsustainable.

I'm reminded of Mondale's claim during the 1984 campaign that both he and Reagan would raise taxes, and differed only in his being honest enough to admit it. The claim was that deficits would make tax increases necessary no matter what. But Reagan got along just fine in his second term without raising taxes to cut the deficit (although this happened in 1990 and 1993).

One reason Mondale proved wrong was that the fiscal situation actually wasn't incredibly dire back then, except over the very long haul. Now it is quite dire, to the point that disaster is looming, probably in the next ten years or so, if we don't get astoundingly lucky or else have a course correction. But no political force can make us do the sane thing before circumstances turn ugly.

As for McCain, it's true that he wasn't and presumably still isn't a dyed in the wool tax cutter. I don't think he actually knows or cares about taxes any more than the average high school student does. And it's true that he took a more responsible stance in 2001 and 2003. But that was at a time when (a) he was furious at Bush for throwing filth at him in the 2000 presidential campaign and (b) he didn't see his future as necessarily linked to the ruling powers in the Republican party. Now he is institutionally committed to reckless tax cutting even if it remains a matter of personal indifference to him.

Readers may have noticed that I've been criticizing McCain a lot in my blog entries but not saying a whole lot about Obama. This reflects that I'm not necessarily sold to a high degree either on Obama personally (although he appears to be intelligent, and the attacks on him have generally been unfounded and idiotic) or on the institutional commitments of a Democratic nominee. My main reason for supporting him, as one clearly can infer from these columns that I do, is that I fear McCain will be incredibly bad. This basically reflects the institutional commitments that I think McCain has via the Bush-Rove Republican party, plus the fact that he appears to be a dangerous warmonger.

Returning to the tax and budgetary realm, I believe we are headed for the shoals of a fiscal disaster unless the Republicans become sane again, at which point bipartisan solutions may become possible. But they need to lose a few more times before that has any chance of happening. In the short term, McCain like Bush will, I fear, act mainly to make things worse - as Obama might too if political constraints are binding enough (although his advisors know better and he appears to be smart enough to understand what they tell him), but at least in far lesser degree.

Saturday, July 12, 2008

Last stand in Vietnam



It's Saturday night here (11 hours later than in NYC), and on Monday morning we start our very long journey back to the States, expecting to be back mid-day on Tuesday (although to our bodies it will be late Tuesday night).

Here are a couple of shots of our Hoi An resort, where we've been spending a pleasant and relaxing last week after the more energetic touring of our earlier days in Vietnam.

Friday, July 11, 2008

More on McCain's "disgrace" comment about Social Security

Fungibility notwithstanding, obviously it would be absurd at this point to deem Social Security's payroll tax revenues as available for any other purpose, such as funding current workers' future benefits, unless one made it a true break-even by treating some other set of equivalent or greater revenues as off the table instead. In that sense, McCain is presumably just showing his ignorance via the "disgrace" comment - perhaps distractedly channeling half-digested talking points from Bush's 2005 Social Security campaign.

But he does actually have a point, which is that absent a clearer link between individual-level taxes and benefits than Social Security currently offers, you get reduced transparency that may have some good effects but also has significant (and to my mind predominant) bad ones.

Keeping the Social Security tax-benefit link unclear has long been rationalized on the left as a device to make the program more progressive than people actually think it is - saying you get your own money back, whereas in fact the hope is that it's being redistributed downward. (This from the benefit formula, although its punch is reduced by the fact that high-income individuals live longer and thus get the life annuity for longer terms.)

But whether or not the muddied tax-benefit link has this arguably desirable effect, it also tends to obscure both generational redistribution from young to old that arguably deserves greater scrutiny, and other quite anomalous redistribution through the program such as from singles and two-earner couples to one-earner couples.

In my Social Security book (see the left-hand side of this blog for a link), I discussed "progressive privatization," a device I thought of much less in terms of the grossly overrated (during the stock market boom) issue of individual investment choice than of making redistribution through the program more transparent.

Anyway, to throw McCain a rare bone here, he tried to explain his comments by arguing that it's unfair for current workers to pay Social Security taxes without their being sure of getting commensurate benefits. One can perhaps credit him with making the point that the program has questionable distributional effects by reason of its obscuring the tax-benefit link (though the problem he refers to is largely a function of sustainability rather than projected benefit levels themselves).

And if that's not enough of a bone, too bad as I have a beach out here in Hoi An to get back to.

Wednesday, July 09, 2008

Semantic disgrace?

McCain has been drawing heat from the liberal blogosphere for calling Social Security an "absolute disgrace" by reason of the fact that young workers' taxes are used to pay seniors' benefits. They rightly note that he is criticizing a core feature of the program since its inception, thereby suggesting that he is at odds with what remains an exceptionally popular set of policies.

Less noted by anyone thus far is the absurdity of caring about the exact details of cash flow. Money is fungible. If everyone paid exactly the same Social Security taxes and received exactly the same Social Security benefits upon retirement, but the exact dollar bills collected via the payroll tax went into special savings accounts and other funds (from government borrowing or taxes) paid the current benefits, would it make any difference? Only an ass would think so, leaving aside political economy claims about how the cash flow details might affect perceptions and thereby change political decisions.

What matters is how much, on balance, different people get and pay throughout their lives, along with interim timing details if one thinks of Social Security and Medicare as forced retirement saving.

Monday, July 07, 2008

Sapa, Vietnam



After a couple of days trekking in Sapa (mountains in northwestern Vietnam, right by China), we have arrived at the Hoi An resort near Danang in southern Vietnam for our final leg out here. Sapa is striking and beautiful, though easiest to get to if you are short (the night train can be a bit cramped for the taller among us).

A new low

John "100 Years" McCain's claim that he will balance the budget by winning the Iraq and Afghanistan wars (permitting outlays in both countries to go to zero?) deserves some sort of gold medal for ludicrousness and audacity. I assume they were laughing as they formulated this one over in campaign central.

To create a perfect circle, perhaps he should announce that his plan to win those wars is to quintuple expenditures there, given the new flexibility created by his having balanced the budget.

Wednesday, July 02, 2008

Mysteries of the U.S. presidential campaign

When you are abroad during a U.S. presidential campaign, even with Internet access most of the time, the stuff that is going on back home can seem a bit mysterious once one catches up with it.

Back in 2004, I spent the big Swift-boating month teaching and vacationing in Australia. So, while I knew from nytimes.com and such that it was happening, I couldn't quite grasp how a home-front wartime deserter was able to trash the other guy based on lies so transparent that they should have been laughed at and then ignored. Nor could I grasp why the Kerry campaign didn't do anything about it.

Now after two days offline at Halong Bay I am trying to grasp this bizarre fake scandal regarding Wesley Clark, who is being savaged for saying things that are indisputably true. I gather he was asked why Obama is qualified to be commander in chief when he has never been shot down in a military plane and spent 5 years in POW camp. He answered that this is not really a qualification to be commander in chief - it doesn't involve running large units, making military decisions, etcetera - and added if anything over-elaborate encomia about how he honors what McCain endured, etcetera, etcetera.

This in turn apparently loosed a wave of hysteria about how he's dishonored America, needs to apologize, and so on ad nauseum. The fact that he was respectful and made an indisputably correct observation - McCain's experience may or may not be significant to one's assessment of his abilities and qualifications, but clearly is not itself c of c experience - just doesn't matter.

We are one crazy country these days, and not I fear headed towards greater sanity.

Halong Bay



A 3-hour drive from Hanoi brought us to Halong Bay, where we stayed for two nights on a reasonably luxurious boat and went kayaking through limestone caves, climbing small hills on the islands, and swimming in the warmth of the bay (off the Gulf of Tonkin). A coupla photos may give the basic feel.